Posts

Correctly Understanding Spirituality

  Spirituality is: A subjectively transformative state of awareness where that subjective entity's narrative-perspective (as it pertains to their narrative of identity) gains empowered peace and clarity with the realization that they are: an integral, living, breathing part of a much larger living breathing whole. Through true spirituality, a person meets themselves more deeply. In turn, this enables them to meet others more deeply. That experience does not need to include the consideration of facts, or arguments, or creeds, or really any philosophical epistemology. The person (not necessarily humans. Other species of apes, for example, can experience this too. But in our case, humans) might only zoom out far enough for their spirituality include: one other person, or a family, or a tribe, or a species, or all life in their local ecosystem, or the global biological ecosystem, or the global ecosystem as it includes soil, the wind and the sun,...

Defending TRUTH and DECENCY Against Apologists

Image
  ​Responding to: " The debate must be Spirituality (consciousness primordial to matter) VS Materialism (matter primordial to consciousness) ... all the rest are just variants of these two philosophical/scientific opposite views." @francesco5581  [First Draft] I'm sorry. But no. There, you are attempting to force a false dichotomy built from a religiously prejudiced premise. First, some "materialists" are also Theists. In fact, literally every bible writer and character were materialists. [See God: An Anatomy    by   Francesca Stavrakopoulou  ] Some atheists are not materialists. There are multiple iterations or "types" of materialism. Some materialists hold to the idea of a conscious prime mover. Some call that a "god". Some don't bother to give it a name or a title. Also, people can be very very spiritual as materialist theists, and as materialist non-theists. Try listening to what Allan Watts said about this, or ...

Defending Sabine Hossenfelder's Honor From A Rando Presuppositional Grifter.

Image
Continuing a comment-discussion from there:   @DonovanWard-xp64  [First draft] Re: 1. "Presuppositional apologetics is not about commandeering anyone 's mind. " -- Literally every Christian apologetic is directly about that. Meanwhile, I didn't merely 'say' it's that. I explained how it works. In other words, I supported my assertion. Whereas, you can only 'say' yours. Let's review, here, what I said about it: 6:05 - 6:46 -- None of us can break through, conquer, or resolve this limit. It will always always be the case that we can only have "knowledge" within the context of our limited access to facts and our limited capacity for reasoning and understanding. Appealing to a Magic Dad ... provides absolutely zero improvement in our access to data, nor our ability to comprehend, nor our ability justify our own cognition. If I accept SpongeBob as my Eternal Hall Monitor, my ability to rationally justify my belief that ...

Some Of The WAYS I Rule Out Christianity (and Islam) as Either "Good" Or "True"'.

Image
[First Draft]  Today, I heard a Christian (on Youtube) say "There is something". [Time Index 11:51, at this video] -- My reply to this claim and to the larger premise of Christian (and Islamic) religions is this: I hope there "is something". And yet, since I'm not a sociopath, I'd rather there "be nothing", if "the something" is anything like what your religion fantasizes about. Although, all claims about an afterlife are meaningless without defining the "i". And that's a huge blind spot for Christianities (plural) and for Islamic religions as well. They don't know how to define it. Until they do, all of their eternity-promises literally mean nothing. However, here is my best attempt to support the general idea of an afterlife: Some species of moths have such a short lifespan that each new year is all-new-moths. But somehow, they all just instinctively know there is 'a place' and ...