Replying To The Claim "Following All Of Jesus' Advice Will Yield Results Which Prove He Was Sent By a Literal "God".

Replying to: 
The YouTube video:

Was Jesus A Real Person? #SHORTS






My initial reply:

 Even if someone followed all the advice in those three chapters of that one book, ... and even if that went very well for them (eventually)

I expect:
in most cases, it wouldn't go well. 

But let's say it always would, for the sake of argument).

How does that prove that a DEITY (whatever that is) sent (or: came as) the advice-giver to Earth?

 Mere mortal, fallible humans give good advice to other humans pretty often.

Does that prove they are gods (or: sent by gods)?


----------------------------------





Jesus Minutes2 hours ago
It's unclear what you mean by goes "very well for them" and "it wouldn't go well". It would "go well" or "it wouldn't go well" in what sense? You probably need to unravel what you are trying to say here before moving on to other questions, since otherwise they don't really follow on in any real logical order.





​ @Jesus Minutes ​ @Jesus Minutes 

It's actually fine to ME to make a general statement, without saying how exactly it would go well

or how it would go badly

(for whomever is following all that advice).

Why is that fine, as a response to the video?

But it's EXACTLY what happened in the video.

Your video doesn't specify what the results would be.

It doesn't say what is meant by good results.

It just make a totally unspecified claim.

Nor does it explain how those (whatever) results

would prove anything about Jesus or (any) "God". So my reply didn't specify either.

If it's illogical for me to:

fail to specify

then

it's illogical for you also, to:

fail to specify.

---

Trying to hold others

to standards that you aren't holding yourself to

is a symptom of:

placing high on the narcissism spectrum.

And this is not surprising to me, to see that happening. Because:

Your entire religion (or "faith") is built on the framework of clinical narcissistic personality disorder.

In any event, it should be you

who specifies first.

Cite any specific advice given

by "Jesus" in those three chapters

which

1. is either:

a.) unique to your religious (or "faith") narrative,

or

b.) originated there in those pages (first time humanity ever heard of such a thing),

and

2. everyone should follow,

and

3. is very likely to yield such fantastic results that:

4. such advice could only have come from a deity:

And then explain (logically) how you reasoned-it-out that such advice could only have come from a literal deity. ?

If you can't do that, then your entire video is just emotionally manipulative (and otherwise meaningless) propaganda.